The Streamlight ProTac HL4 is a durable, ultra high-power flashlight, that can use either disposable CR123 lithium batteries or 18650 rechargeable batteries (not included). At 8.6″ long and a head 2.4″ in diameter this is a large flashlight. The HL4 comes with four CR123 batteries and a heavy, and sells for about $100 (does NOT come with a holster). It does NOT include rechargeable batteries but can operate on two 18650 rechargeable batteries.
The HL4 has a poly covered machined aluminum body. This large tactical light generates a remarkable 2,200 lumens at 30,000 candelas. The front and rear have semi-aggressive strike bezels that would make an effective weapon. The body is easy and comfortable to grip especially with the poly cover.

• Construction: The HL4 is machined from aircraft grade aluminum that has a poly cover and semi-aggressive striking bezels on both the head and tail. The threads are tight and smooth and sealed with an O-ring.
• Size: The HL4 is large (8.6″ long) and would work well on a service belt.
• Waterproof: The HL4 is rated at IPX7 waterproof.
• Features: Has high, strobe, and low modes. You can also change the light mode using the Ten-Tap programming feature.
• Batteries: This light can use either two rechargeable 18650 batteries or four CR123 lithium batteries. Three rails in side the body that allow it to use batteries of different diameters. Recharge the 18650 batteries using a separately available charger.
• Light Output: (high) 2,200 lumens at 30,000 candelas for 1.75 hours, (medium) 600 lumens at 8,300 candelas for 4 hours, (low) 60 lumens at 8,000 candelas for 43 hours.

Advantages

This is an ultra high-power flashlight that can use either 18650, rechargeable batteries or CR123 batteries. Things I like about the HL4:

• Built to use either rechargeable or disposable batteries. Some rechargeable lights cannot use alternate batteries. Consequently, if those lights lose power when you are in the field then you are stuck without a light. With the HL4 you can run on rechargeable batteries but use CR123s as a backup. I would never purchase a flashlight that could not use backup batteries.
• You DO need a separate charger and 18650 batteries for this flashlight. You cannot directly charge the batteries in the flashlight.

Disadvantages

The ProTac HL4 is an excellent ultra high-power flashlight. My only issues with the flashlight are

• Large size
• Rechargeable batteries and charger sold separately
• No case included
• For heavy use the rechargeable batteries would have to be manually replaced — you cannot simply plug in the flashlight to recharge the batteries

Recommendations

If you are looking for a high-power tactical light then this is a good choice. This would be a good choice for first responders with the caveat being that the rechargeable batteries must be swapped when drained.

The Streamlight Siege is just a good, solid product that is well constructed and does its job very well. The Siege sells for about $30-40 and runs on three D-cell batteries. When browsing in a store this might be a product that you would quickly pass by. It is more expensive than similar products and is not flashy. However, in my opinion, this is the product to purchase.

It has three white light modes and two red light modes:

• Low white light: 33 lumens runs for 295 hours
• Medium white light: 175 lumens runs for 70 hours
• High white light: 340 lumens runs for 30 hours
• High red light: 10 lumens runs for 235 hours (9.7 days)
• Red flashing SOS mode for emergency signaling: 10 lumens runs 430 hours (17.9 days)

Press the power button to activate the light, and press again to move through the lighting modes. Press and hold the button to toggle between white light and red light modes. The lantern can be hung right-side up or upside down. The handle allows the lantern to be hung on the edge of tables, cords, or branches. You can remove the diffuser cover and hang the Siege upside down to provide more even lighting (works well inside tents).

The selling points for me with this lantern are the durability and the red light. The Siege is very durable and can easily withstand one meter drops onto concrete. It is IPX7 waterproof and can be submerged in water for 30 minutes and it floats. The red light can be used for emergency signaling. If you have car trouble you can put the Siege in red blinking mode to alert others. The flat areas on the main body help eliminate rolling and the square rubber feet on the base help it to not slip.

When I worked at an outdoors store I would routinely show this lantern to customers. They would be unimpressed since they can purchase a similar looking lantern for about $10. Then I would drop the Siege onto the hard floor (thin, carpet covered concrete). I would then say that in an emergency situation you need to the light to function even when subject to dropping and abuse. That would usually close the sale.

Conclusion

This is a larger, higher-output lantern is not flashy or gimmicky. It is just a bright, durable, effective, and affordable lantern. This product does one job and does it very well. If you need a smaller lantern then consider the Streamlight Siege AA.

Energizer TUF2AAPE. This light is bright (250 lumens), durable (high impact plastic case), very affordable (about $16), and it uses 2 AA batteries. This is just a good, basic, bright, inexpensive light. The Energizer is IPX4 water resistant and will withstand a 7 meter drop (about 23′).

Advantages

• Very tough and will withstand a 7 meter drop
• Long battery life of 5 hours on high-power
• Very long battery life of 50 hours on low-power
• Very low cost

Disadvantages

• Non-tactical light
• Larger in size

The Energizer produces a more even beam that does NOT have an intense hotspot.

The Streamlight ProTac HL USB is a durable, rechargeable, high-power flashlight. It is on the larger side and sells for around $100-$140. The machined aluminum body fits nicely in the palm of my hand and the larger body extends well past my palm. This rugged tactical light generates 850 lumens with 10,000 candelas which should temporarily blind an attacker (has high-beam and strobe). The front and rear have semi-aggressive strike bezels that would make an effective weapon. The body is knurled and very easy and comfortable to grip.

• Construction: The light is machined from aircraft grade aluminum and it has a semi-aggressive striking bezels on both the head and tail. The threads are tight and smooth and sealed with an O-ring.
• Size: The ProTac HL UB is larger than my StreamLight ProTac HL. It would work well on a belt holster but would be too large for a concealable light. This light has a slightly larger body diameter than the ProTac HL and it can accept an 18650 rechargeable battery.
• Waterproof: The light is rated at IPX4 which means that it is water resistant against rain and splashes. This lower level of water sealing is probably due to the USB charging connector.
• Features: Has high, strobe, and low modes. You can also change the light mode using the Ten-Tap programming feature.
• Batteries: This light can use either a rechargeable 18650 battery or two CR123 lithium batteries. Three rails in side the body that allow it to use batteries of different diameters. The light includes a USB charging cable that can be plugged directly into the body of the light.
• Beam Pattern: 48″ x 6″ at 3′ (Beam Scale)

The ProTac HL USB has a higher lumen and lower candela rating than my ProTac HL. This means that the HL USB generates a brighter overall beam (higher lumens) with less intensity in the middle of the beam (low candelas). The lens is also the same diameter as the body.

Advantages

This is a good, solid, high-power, rechargeable flashlight. Things I like about this light:

• Built to be rechargeable but you can use disposable batteries also. Some rechargeable lights cannot use alternate batteries. Consequently, if those lights lose power when you are in the field then you are stuck without a light. With the HL you can run on the rechargeable battery but use CR123s as a backup. I would never purchase a flashlight that could not use backup batteries.
• You do NOT need a charger for this flashlight. Simply connect the USB cable to charge the battery.
• The beam pattern does have a good hot spot but it gives a more even beam pattern.

Disadvantages

The ProTac HL USB is a very good light but it is not perfect. Here are some minor issues that I have with this light:

• The watersealing is only IPX4 and I prefer lights that are IPX7 or greater.
• The HL USB is a larger light and I prefer smaller lights.
• While the light is not outrageously priced it is priced on the high side for me.

Recommendations

If you are looking for an everyday, tactical light then I would NOT choose the HL USB. It is large and would be difficult to conceal for everyday carry. If you need to use the light extensively then a rechargeable light is extremely practical. The standard 18650 rechargeable battery is easy to replace. You can carry CR123s to use as backup batteries in the field. If you use your flashlight extensively, need to generate a lot of light, and do not need to conceal the light then the ProTac HL USB is a solid alternative.

The Nitecore P12 is an amazing, durable, and high-power flashlight. I only got to examine it for a few minutes at a local outdoors retailer and I was able to put it through some of its paces and compare it with my Streamlight 1L-1AA light. The diameter of the P12 is 1″, about 5.5″ long, sells for about $60, and can output 1000 lumens with 12,450 candelas. It is roughly the size of my Streamlight ProTac HL but it does not have the enlarged front head. The machined aluminum body appears to be of top-notch construction. The knurling makes the body of the light easy and comfortable to grip. It has a tail button and a side selector switch. It is powered by either 2 CR123 batteries or one 18650 rechargeable battery.

Advantages

This light has some really nice features including:

• Very bright with a maximum output of 1,000 lumens
• Decent candela power at 12,450 to give the beam some distance
• Side selector switch to set light output mode
• Nicely machined aluminum body
• IPX8 waterproof (submersible)
• Can use rechargeable 18650 battery or two CR123s
• Side switch can show current battery voltage

I did not think that I would like a side selector switch but I was mistaken. You can activate the light and set the output mode using the side switch. Then next time you activate the light it will default to that setting. This is a REALLY nice feature. If I want to use my flashlight in tactical strobe mode then I can select that mode, turn off the light, and when I activate the light again it defaults to strobe mode (or whichever mode was selected). This means I can single-click into whatever mode I want. This is REALLY nice. The feel of the button is good and the flashlight appears to be v waery well constructed. The cost is extremely reasonable for a flashlight of this caliber.

Disadvantages

While this appears to be an excellent light it is just a bit larger than I prefer as an everyday carry (EDC) light. With an EDC light I want to be able to easily conceal the light in a pocket. This light would work well on a belt holster but this creates another issue. With I carry a light on my belt I use a holster with an elastic, friction grip. If I need to grab the light quickly I have to overcome the friction fitting of the holster. My ProTac HL light has a larger head making it easier to grasp and remove from the holster. The P12 body is the same diameter and would be slightly more difficult to remove from certain belt holsters. The P12 has a tactical strike bezel on the tail but a smooth bezel on the lens. While this is not a deal breaker I would prefer to have a tactical strike bezel on the front lens also. These are minor points. I did find some user reviews that stated that the light is not as durable as others. I could NOT verify these claims but saw these in the comments of YouTube review videos.

Additional Reviews & Information

Review the Light

The StreamLight Stylus Pro is a small, non-tactical flashlight that packs a good amount of lighting in a small package. It is about the size of a highlighter pen and is easy to carry. My headlamp uses AAA batteries and I use the Stylus Pro as a backup light. It uses the same batteries and my headlamp, has a long runtime, is very lightweight, and relatively bright. When building your hiking and emergency packs try to use devices that use the same type of batteries.

Features include:

• Beam: 90 lumens at 860 candela with 58m beam
• Runtime: A very impressive 6.5 hour runtime from two AAA batteries
• Holster: Tear-resistant nylon holster included
• Construction: Anodized aircraft aluminum with polycarbonate lens
• Durability: IPX4 water-resistant and impact resistant to 1 meter
• Size/Weight: About the size of a marker (5.3″ long) and 1.64 oz
• Beam Pattern: 48″ x 10″ at 3′ (Beam Scale)
• Colors: Black, silver, blue, red, orange, green
• Cost: About $20-$30

It is just a good, basic, small flashlight that is extremely easy to carry and use. It has a very long run time, uses two AAA batteries, and has two modes (ON and OFF), and the body is machined from aircraft aluminum. Once again StreamLight created a simple product that does its job very well. At less than $25 it is affordable and well worth that price.

This light is NOT a replacement for a high-powered tactical flashlight but it is a good addition to your light collection. If you want to carry a basic, non-tactical flashlight then this one is small, affordable, easy to carry, and has a very long runtime.

Recommendation

This is an excellent light to include in a hiking and emergency kit. You should have two forms of light in your kits and these two lights should use the same type of batteries. I use a Black Diamond Spot headlamp as my primary light and a Stylus Pro as my backup light. Both use AAA batteries and both have a very long runtime.

The Streamlight Siege AA is not flashy and does not appear particularly interesting when displayed on a retail shelf. However, this product should grab your attention. This is a solid product that works very well and is well constructed. The Siege AA sells for about $25-$40 and runs on three AA batteries.

Key features include:

• Rugged and can withstand 2 meter drops to concrete
• IPX7 Waterproof, floats, and can be submersed 1 meter for 30 minutes
• Limited lifetime warranty
• Uses readily available AA batteries
• Red light to preserve night vision and 3-blink distress signal
• Optional magnetic base is especially nice for vehicle kit lanterns

Lighting Modes

It has three white light modes and two red light modes:

• Low white light: 50 lumens runs for 37 hours
• Medium white light: 100 lumens runs for 15.5 hours
• High white light: 200 lumens runs for 7 hours
• High red light: 0.7 lumens runs for 192 hours (8 days)
• Red flashing SOS mode for emergency signaling: 0.7 lumens runs 288 hours (12 days)

Press the power button to activate the light, and press again to move through the lighting modes. Press and hold the button to toggle between white light and red light modes. The lantern can be hung right-side up or upside down. The handle allows the lantern to be hung on the edge of tables, cords, or branches. You can remove the diffuser cover and hang the Siege upside down to provide more even lighting (works well inside tents).

Power

The Siege AA can operate using disposable or rechargeable batteries. If you need to operate off-gird then consider using the Goal Zero Guide 10 to charge NiMh AA batteries for the Siege. The power fail voltage is about 1.12v.

Recommendations

The selling points for me with this lantern are the durability and the red light. The Siege is very durable and can easily withstand 2-meter drops. It is IPX7 waterproof, floats, and can be submerged for 30 minutes. The red light can be used for emergency signaling. If you have car trouble you can put the Siege in red blinking mode to alert others. The flat areas on the main body help eliminate rolling and the square rubber feet on the base help it to not slip. An optional magnetic base is also available.

I recommend having at least one Siege AA in your house in case the power fails. For home use you might consider the larger Siege that uses D-cell batteries and has a very long runtime. I have one Siege AA in my car and one in the house. The one in my car has the optional magnetic base to secure it if I need to use it as a distress beacon. Since it is waterproof it would be an effective signal lantern even in adverse weather conditions.

Conclusion

The Siege AA is not flashy or gimmicky. It is just a good basic, extremely durable, effective, and affordable lantern. This product does one job and does it very well. If you want a larger lantern with more light output then consider the Streamlight Siege which is the big brother to the Siege AA. Streamlight also makes a Magnetic Base for the Siege AA.

The Streamlight ProTac HL is a really nice, durable, and high-power flashlight. It is on the larger side and sells for $70-$100. The machined aluminum body of the light fits in the palm of my hand and the larger head extends past my palm. This is an extremely rugged tactical light that generates a 750 beam with 18,300 candelas. This light output is sufficient to temporarily blind an attacker using either the high-beam or strobe modes. The front and read caps have a semi-aggressive pattern that would be effective if it was used as a striking weapon. The grip areas of the light was knurled to make it easy to grip.

• Construction: The light is machined from aircraft grade aluminum and it has a fairly aggressive striking pattern on both the head and tail. The threads are tight and very smooth and an O-ring provides additional water sealing.
• Size: 5.43″ (13.8cm) long, 1″ (2.54cm) barrel diameter, 1.44″ (3.7cm) head diameter. The ProTac HL is a bit large to carry in a pocket but easy to carry on a belt. The body diameter is large enough to provide a good grip and the head protrudes enough to provide a good striking surface.
• Waterproof: IPX7 waterproof to 1 meter for 30 minutes.
• Durability: Withstands 1-meter drop.
• Features: High, strobe, low modes, and Ten-Tap programming.
• Light Output: (high) 750 lumens at 18,300 candelas for 1.25 hours, (low) 35 lumens at 900 candelas for 18 hours.
• Beam Pattern: 50″ x 7″ at 3′ (Beam Scale)
• Power Fail: No low battery indicator and the flashlight will fail when the CR-123 battery gets to 2.5v.

At my job we are routinely warned to walk to our cars in pairs late at night. When I walk to my car I always have this light in my hand. The diameter of the light is just the right size for my grip, it is lightweight, but substantial enough to be effective should the need arise.

Additional Reviews & Information

• Streamlight HL-X review (replacement for HL)
• Fenix UC35 review (similar style flashlight)
• OLight M2R review (similar style flashlight)
• Luke Fosberg Review

The Streamlight ProTac 1L-1AA is one of my favorite flashlights because it does so many things well. This small light fits well in the palm of my hand and is just long enough to protract slightly when gripped. It sells for between about $40-$60 and generates a 350 lumen beam with 6,500 candelas. The dual fuel option was a huge factor in my decision to purchase this light. The front and read caps have a semi-aggressive pattern that would be effective if it was used as a striking weapon. The grip areas of the light was knurled to make it easy to grip.

• Construction: The 1L-1AA is machined from aircraft grade aluminum and has a fairly aggressive striking pattern on both the head and tail. The threads are tight and very smooth and an O-ring provides additional water sealing.
• Size: At 4.5″ long and 0.95″ diameter (head, 0.85″ barrel) it is small enough to fit in my pants pocket but large enough to fit with width of my palm. The diameter is just large enough for my fingers to wrap around the body of the light.
• Batteries: A HUGE advantage of the 1L-1AA is it can use either a CR123 battery to produce 350 lumens or a AA to produce 150 lumens. I use the CR123 but it is nice to know that I could use a AA as a backup. The lower battery contact is spring loaded to accommodate the larger AA battery directly. This feature distinguishes this light from all others that I have seen.
• Battery Life: CR-123 (high) 350 lumens for 1.5 hours, (low) 40 lumens for 14 hours
  AA Alkaline (high) 150 lumens for 1 hour 20 minutes, (low) 40 lumens for 7.5 hours
  AA Lithium (high) 350 lumens for 4.25 hours, (low) 40 lumens for 14 hours
• Waterproof: IPX7 waterproof to 1 meter for 30 minutes.
• Durability: Withstands 1-meter drop.
• Price: $40-$60 which is a very fair price for a flashlight of this quality.
• Features: High/strobe/low modes and Ten-Tap Programming to switch to High/Low or Low/High mode.
• Beam Pattern: 40″ x 7″ at 3′ (Beam Scale)
• Power Fail: No low battery indicator and the flashlight will fail when the AA battery gets to 1.18v, or the CR-123 battery gets to 2.83v.

If you want an everyday carry (EDC) flashlight then this is normally the one that I recommend. It is a good size for most people, generates a bright beam, and uses duel fuel. If you have larger hands then consider the Streamlight 2L or one of the longer flashlights.

Advantages

This is my personal everyday carry (EDC) light. I took months deciding which flashlight to purchase and this was my choice. I keep trying to find a better light and I keep coming back to this one. Some of the reasons I really like this flashlight:

• 350 lumens on high and 40 lumens on low
• Aluminum construction with tactical bezels on the front and back
• Small size allows me to easily conceal it in my pants pocket
• Large enough to fit all the way across my palm
• Double sided clip
• Dual battery so I can use an AA if necessary

Disadvantages

This is still my favorite flashlight but there are a few minor flaws in this product.

• No low battery indicator: This light will work fine until the batteries get low and then it will stop working with very little warning. If you needed to light in a tactical situation and the batteries were low you may have a completely non-working light.
• Others have reported that the clip will easily lose its shape and not grip the body of the light over time. I have not experienced these issues and have been carrying the flashlight daily for well over a year.
• The light does not tail-stand easily. While this is a disadvantage if you want to tail-stand the light it means that the button is easier to press use to less material on the back of the light.

These are minor disadvantages and should NOT dissuade you from purchasing this light. This is still my favorite everyday carry flashlight.

Additional Reviews & Information

• Bravo Review
• Wise Men Company Review